Season review: four numbers from your cards, and why to save them before UK winter scores count
Most club golfers finish the summer knowing their Index and the hole that ruined the club championship. Their score history knows a great deal more. Here are four numbers you can take from your cards in an evening, what each one says about your game, and why British golfers should save their record now, since winter scores keep counting.
In brief
- Great Britain and Ireland have no closed season, so acceptable winter cards push summer rounds out of your last twenty. Screenshot your record before you play again.
- Count doubles or worse per round, note what caused each one, and look for the two or three holes where they keep happening. A different club off the tee costs nothing.
- Average your score over par on par 3s, par 4s and par 5s. Par 4s usually cost the most, so look for the type of hole that is out of step with the others.
- Compare the opening three holes with the rest of the round, and set your Index, the best eight of twenty differentials, beside the average of all twenty.
The clocks have gone back, the last medal of the summer has been played and most courses are now on preferred lies, with a temporary green or two waiting in the corner of the fairway. Ask a club golfer how the year went and you will usually get two things: the Handicap Index on the app, and the story of a seven on a par 4 that still hurts. Neither tells you much. Somewhere in your record there are twenty or thirty rounds that know exactly where the shots went, and getting the truth out of them takes one wet evening, a pen and four simple numbers. There is a British twist, too. Our handicap system has no closed season, so the rounds you play this winter will start pushing the summer out of your record. If you want to look back at the season you actually had, the time to do it is before December’s cards arrive.
Why one round lies and a season does not
Any single round comes with an excuse attached. The wind got up on the back nine, the greens had just been hollow-tined, you were drawn with someone who plays at the speed of continental drift. All of that may be true, and none of it helps you decide what to work on, because one card is far too small a sample to show a habit.
Put a whole season on one sheet of paper and the excuses start to cancel out. The windy days and the lucky bounces are still there, but they are spread thinly across twenty rounds, and what is left standing is your real game. It is common for a golfer who blames the driver to discover that the driver costs about a shot a round and the chipping costs three. Winter is also when the money gets spent, on a course of lessons, a new hybrid or a simulator membership, and spending it on the evidence of a whole year is rather better than spending it on the memory of last Saturday.
Where your season’s scores live in the UK
England. If your home club is in England, your record sits in the My England Golf app, known as MyEG. General play cards go in hole by hole, and once a card is submitted it moves into your scorecard history, where the app lets you open the rounds on your handicap record and see the score on every hole. Since April 2024 the app has also had an optional My Stats section for fairways, greens in regulation, putts and penalty shots. Nobody has to fill it in for handicap purposes, but if you did, you have more to work with than most. Golfers without a club can hold an Index through England Golf’s iGolf subscription.
Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. Scottish Golf has its own app, My Scottish Golf, and the Wales Golf app keeps a scoring history with hole-by-hole records for each round. In Northern Ireland the handicap is run by Golf Ireland. Since June 2023 the four unions have accepted general play scores across the borders, so a round at a Welsh links can sit on an English member’s record. Wherever you are, the principle is the same: open the history, and the raw material for this review is already there.
No closed season, and what that means for the review. In the colder American states, many associations close score posting for the winter. Not here. Guidance written for club managers in Great Britain and Ireland states plainly that the World Handicap System has no off season in GB&I and that a separate winter handicap no longer exists. A card can still count with no more than two temporary greens on an 18-hole course, or one on a nine-hole layout, and preferred lies are allowed on closely mown areas as long as the ball is placed within six inches of where it lay. Your club decides on the day whether the course meets those conditions. The practical consequence is that your Index keeps moving all winter, because every acceptable card pushes the oldest one out of your last twenty. So before you play again, take a screenshot or a printout of your current twenty differentials. That snapshot is your summer season, and it is what you will analyse.
Your club’s competition results. The software your club uses to run medals and Stablefords often keeps the full hole-by-hole card for every competition you entered. If a round is missing from your app or you lost the paper card, it is worth a look there before you give up on it.
A word on other apps. Scorekeeping apps and shot-tracking sensors can work out some of these figures for you, but they only cover the rounds you remembered to record with them. Panxis Golf has no commercial link with any app and earns no commission.
Setting up the sheet
Draw a grid with a row for each round. Across the top write the date, the gross score and three columns for how many over par you were on the par 3s, the par 4s and the par 5s. If your history holds hole-by-hole scores, add a column for the number of double bogeys or worse and another for your score over par across the 1st, 2nd and 3rd. Fifteen rounds will do, and twenty or more is better.
Use the score you really made. The adjusted gross score on your record caps each hole at net double bogey, and those capped holes are precisely the ones you want to see in full. And keep the horrors in. A review that quietly drops the day you shot 104 in a gale describes somebody else.
The blow-up holes
Start with the number most people get wrong from memory. Count every double bogey or worse across the season and divide by the number of rounds. Golfers tend to remember the quadruple on the 11th in the club championship and forget the four or five ordinary doubles scattered through the summer, so the figure on the sheet is usually higher than the one in their head.
For a mid-handicapper, bogeys are not the problem. A five on a long par 4 into the wind is a perfectly respectable score. The damage is done by the sixes and sevens, which turn a decent 84 into a disappointing 93, and they nearly always come from one of three places: a penalty drop, a recovery shot that did not recover, or a chip or bunker shot that left you in trouble again. If you can, write the cause beside each double. By the end of the sheet one of the three will be doing most of the harm.
Then look at the holes themselves. On your home course, a couple of holes probably account for far more than their share of the damage. Perhaps it is the dogleg with out of bounds down the right, or the par 3 over the pond. Taking a 5-wood off that tee, or aiming at the fat side of that green, costs nothing and works from the first round in spring.
Par 3s, par 4s and par 5s
Total how many over par you were on each type of hole and divide by the number of holes of that type you played. Your three averages might read plus 0.8 on par 3s, plus 1.4 on par 4s and plus 0.7 on par 5s. Do not panic about the middle one. A large Shot Scope data study published by MyGolfSpy found that par 4s produced the highest average score relative to par and par 5s the lowest, at every handicap level. What matters is which average sits out of line with the others.
Par 3s that cost far more than expected usually point at the irons, since a par 3 is one approach shot and then whatever the short game can save. Par 5s that cost more than par 4s are rare and tend to be a thinking problem, the result of going for the green in two from 230 yards or laying up to an awkward 70 yards instead of a full wedge. If the par 4s are well clear of the other two, split them into those under 380 yards and those over. If the trouble is only on the long ones, it is distance and the second shot. If it is everywhere, look at the tee shot.
The opening three
Add up your score over par on the first three holes for the whole season and compare it with any other run of three holes. A surprising number of club golfers find they give away a shot or more before they reach the 4th.
That is almost never a swing fault. It is the dash from the car park, the driver swung cold on a frosty tee, or forty range balls thrashed at full speed and a body that is already tired by the first green. A short warm-up you repeat in the same order every time will fix more than a lesson, and our warm-up routine for UK golfers sets one out that works even at clubs without a range. Plenty of good club players also leave the driver in the bag on the 1st until they are loose. If your pattern runs the other way, a strong start and a fading finish, think about food, water and concentration over four and a half hours rather than technique.
Your Index against your typical day
Finally, the number that explains why so many golfers feel they never play to their handicap. Under the World Handicap System your Index is the average of the best eight Score Differentials from your most recent twenty. It describes your good days, by design.
Using the snapshot you saved, average all twenty differentials and compare that figure with your Index. Say the Index is 14.2 and the average of all twenty is 18.0. That gap of nearly four shots tells you your best golf is a long way above your normal golf, and the shots are being lost on the bad days rather than in the swing itself. A golfer with a gap of a shot or so is consistent and needs to lift the whole level, which means technique and practice. A golfer with a wide gap should look hard at the bad rounds. Were they early tee times, away fixtures, cold days, competitions? Often the answer is a habit, such as skipping the warm-up or chasing the round after one bad hole, and a habit is cheaper to change than a swing.
Turning four numbers into one winter job
Write the four results on a single line and pick one priority. Not four. The figure most out of line with the others becomes the winter project, and the rest can wait for spring. A wide gap and doubles clustered on the same holes call for strategy and routine rather than buckets of balls. A narrow gap and costly par 3s call for iron work, which a few hours in a simulator bay can help with. A slow start calls for a warm-up, and you can write that tonight.
Next season, give yourself more to work with by noting a few tallies on the back of the card as you play. Our piece on five tallies on the back of your medal card explains which ones are worth the bother. And if the arithmetic of the Index still feels like a black box, our worked example of a Handicap Index takes one card through the whole calculation.
Your season review, in short
- Save a screenshot of your twenty differentials now, before winter cards push the summer rounds out of your record.
- Count doubles or worse per round, write down what caused each one, and find the holes where they keep happening.
- Work out your average over par on par 3s, par 4s and par 5s, and look for the one that is out of step.
- Compare the opening three holes with the rest of the round. A costly start is usually a warm-up problem.
- Set your Index beside the average of all twenty differentials to see how far your usual game sits from your best.
- Choose one priority for the winter, and run the same sums again next autumn.
None of this needs a gadget or a spreadsheet course. It needs an evening and a little honesty, and it turns a summer of half-remembered stories into a short list of facts. The golfers who improve over a British winter are seldom the ones who hit the most balls. They are the ones who know which balls to hit.






