Skip to content
Trends

Season review: four numbers from your scorecards, and why this is the week to do it in the U.S.

Most golfers end the season remembering their Index and two bad holes. Twenty rounds of scores say much more than that. Here are four numbers you can pull from your score history in an evening, what each one means, and how to choose one thing to work on this winter.

La rédaction Panxis Golf, U.S. desk (Mark Sullivan) · · 10 min
A lone golfer, his trolley beside him, finishes his swing on a rolling fairway under a hazy sky
Photo Anthony / Pexels

In brief

  • Your Handicap Index is the average of your best eight Score Differentials out of twenty. Compare it with the average of all twenty to measure how far your usual game is from your best.
  • Average your score over par on par 3s, par 4s and par 5s. Par 4s are usually the most expensive, so look for the type of hole that is out of line with the others.
  • Count doubles or worse per round, write down the cause, and find the two or three holes where they keep happening. A different club off the tee costs nothing.
  • Compare the first three holes with the rest of the round. Many state associations close posting in mid-November, so your GHIN history is now final for the year.

By the third week of November, a lot of golfers in the northern states have played their last round that counts. The clubs go into the garage, the scorecards go into a drawer, and the only thing most people remember about the season is the Handicap Index on the app and two or three holes they would rather forget. That is a waste of the best data you will ever have on your own game. A season of scores, even scores with nothing else written on the card, can tell you where your strokes went and what to work on over the winter. You do not need a launch monitor, a shot-tracking system or a spreadsheet course. You need about an hour, your score history and four numbers.

Why the end of the season is the right moment

During the season, every round feels like its own story. You played badly because it was windy, you played well because you were with friends who relax you, you lost the round on the 14th because of a bad bounce. Each explanation is true and none of them is useful, because one round is too small to show a pattern.

Twenty or thirty rounds are a different matter. The bad bounces and the windy days are still in there, but they are spread across the whole season, and what remains when you add everything up is your real game. A golfer who thinks the driver is the problem often discovers, once the season is laid out on one page, that the driver costs a stroke a round and something else costs four.

There is also a practical reason. Winter is when most golfers decide what to practice, which lesson to book, or whether to buy a new club. Making that decision with a season of evidence in front of you is very different from making it with the memory of your last bad round.

What you need before you start

Gather every score you can find. The most reliable source is the score history in your handicap account, because it lists every round you posted with the date, the course, the tees and the Score Differential. If you posted hole by hole, you also have the score on each hole. Add the paper cards from your bag and your car, and any rounds you kept on a phone app.

Then make one table, on paper or on a screen. One line per round, and five columns: the date, the gross score, the score over par on par 3s, on par 4s and on par 5s. If you have the hole-by-hole scores, add a column for the number of holes where you made double bogey or worse, and one for your score over par on the first three holes. That is all. Fifteen rounds is enough to start, and anything above twenty is good.

Two warnings before you count. Use the gross score you actually made, not the adjusted score posted for handicap, because the adjustment caps the very holes you want to see. And keep the rounds you would prefer to forget. A season review that leaves out the bad days describes a golfer you are not.

Number one: the gap between your Index and your average round

Your Handicap Index is the average of the best eight Score Differentials among your most recent twenty. That is how the World Handicap System is built, and it means the Index describes your good days, not your typical day. Most golfers know this in theory and forget it in practice, which is why so many of them feel they never play to their handicap.

Take the average of all twenty differentials, not just the best eight, and compare it with your Index. The difference is your gap. A small gap means you are a steady player whose good and bad days are close together. A large gap means your best golf is much better than your usual golf, and the strokes are in the bad days rather than in your swing as such.

That distinction changes the winter plan. A steady golfer with a small gap needs to raise the whole level, which usually means technique and practice. A golfer with a large gap needs to find out what happens on the bad days. Look at those rounds specifically. Were they early in the morning, after a long drive to the course, on a particular layout, in competition? Often the answer is a habit, such as no warm-up, or a strategy that falls apart once the first bad hole arrives, and that is cheaper to fix than a swing.

Number two: your score against par on par 3s, par 4s and par 5s

Add up how many strokes over par you were on each type of hole across the season, then divide by the number of holes of that type you played. You get three averages, for example plus 0.9 on par 3s, plus 1.3 on par 4s and plus 1.1 on par 5s.

For most amateurs, par 4s are the most expensive holes. A large Shot Scope data study published by MyGolfSpy found that par 4s gave the highest average score relative to par and par 5s the lowest, across handicap levels. So the useful question is not which number is highest, it is which number is out of line with the others.

A high par-3 average points at the iron game, because a par 3 is a single approach shot followed by the short game. A high par-5 average is unusual and often a strategy problem: golfers who try to reach in two, or who hit a layup to an awkward distance, give back the stroke the extra length should have given them. A par-4 average far above the other two suggests the tee shot and the second shot together, and it is worth splitting your par 4s by length, under 380 yards and over, to see whether the trouble is everywhere or only on the long ones.

Number three: double bogeys or worse per round

Count the holes where you made double bogey or worse, and divide by the number of rounds. This is the number that most often surprises people, because memory keeps the triple on the 7th and quietly drops the three ordinary doubles that came later.

For a mid-handicap golfer, the bogeys are not what decides the score. Bogey is the normal result on a hard par 4. The doubles and the triples are where a round of 88 becomes a round of 96, and they usually have three causes: a penalty stroke, a recovery that did not recover, and a chip or bunker shot that stayed in trouble. If your hole-by-hole history lets you, write the cause next to each double. Within a season you will see which of the three dominates.

Then look at where they happened. On the courses you play most, the same two or three holes tend to collect a large share of the doubles. That is the cheapest improvement in golf. Changing the club off the tee on those holes, or playing to the safe side of a green guarded by water, costs nothing and works the first day of next season.

Number four: the first three holes

Add up your score over par on holes one to three across the season, and compare the average with your average on any other three-hole stretch. Many golfers find that the opening holes cost them noticeably more than the rest of the round.

If that is you, the cause is almost never technical. It is arriving late, swinging a driver cold, or hitting a range bucket at full speed and then starting the round tired. The fix is a warm-up you repeat every time: a few short pitches, a few putts at different lengths to set the speed, then a handful of full swings building up to the driver. Ten minutes, the same order every time. It is also worth looking at the first tee shot itself. A three-wood or a hybrid off the first tee, until the body is warm, is a common choice among good club players for a reason.

A strong start and a weak finish is a different pattern. It points at fitness, food and water, or concentration over four and a half hours, and that is something the winter can fix too.

From four numbers to a winter plan

Write the four results on one line and choose one priority, not four. The number that is most out of line is your plan for the winter, and the others can wait for spring. A golfer with a large gap and many doubles on the same holes needs strategy and routine more than practice balls. A golfer with a small gap and an expensive par-3 average needs iron work. A golfer whose first three holes cost two extra strokes needs a warm-up, which can be written tonight.

If you want to go further next season, start keeping a few shot statistics on the card as well: fairways, greens, putts and penalties. We explained that method in our guide to the five numbers worth tracking during a round. The season review uses what you already have, and the tracking gives you more to work with next November.

Where to find your season’s numbers in the U.S.

Your GHIN score history. The GHIN app and ghin.com list every score you posted with its date, course, tees and differential. The app offers three ways to post a score: total score, hole by hole, or hole by hole with stats such as putts, greens and fairways. If you posted totals only, you will have numbers one and, in part, three. If you posted hole by hole, you have all four. The USGA’s help pages say that stats can also be added afterward to a score that was posted hole by hole, so a few evenings with your old cards can fill the gaps.

The inactive season. Many state associations close score posting for the winter, and scores made in an inactive season are not acceptable for handicap purposes. According to the schedule published by the USGA, the Connecticut State Golf Association’s active season runs from April 1 to November 15, the Colorado Golf Association’s from March 15 to November 15, and the Maryland State Golf Association’s from March 15 to November 30. Washington Golf closes on November 15 and reopens on March 1. Areas not on the USGA list, such as much of the South and the Southwest, post all year. Check the current dates with your own association. If your posting season has just closed, your score history is final for the year, which makes this the right week for the review.

Club and association tournament software. If you played club events, the results pages often keep hole-by-hole scores for every round, even when you only posted a total yourself. They are worth a search before you give up on a missing card.

Phone apps and tracking systems. Free scorekeeping apps often calculate par-3, par-4 and par-5 averages for you once the scores are in. Shot-tracking systems with sensors go further and produce strokes gained, but they only cover the rounds you played with them. Panxis Golf has no commercial relationship with any app or system and earns no commission.

What to take from your season

  • Your Index is the average of your best eight differentials out of twenty. Compare it with the average of all twenty to see how far your usual game is from your best.
  • Average your score over par on par 3s, par 4s and par 5s, and look for the one that is out of line with the others.
  • Count doubles or worse per round, note the cause, and find the two or three holes where they keep happening.
  • Compare the first three holes with the rest of the round. A costly start is usually fixed by a warm-up, not a lesson.
  • Pick one priority for the winter and measure again next November.

A season review takes an evening, and it turns twenty rounds of half-remembered stories into a short list of facts. The golfers who improve over the winter are rarely the ones who practice most. They are the ones who know what to practice.

One article a day not enough?

The monthly letter gathers what was worth reading, without the noise.

Also worth reading

Parcours de notre annuaire

Point O’ Woods Golf & Country Club

Near Benton Harbor, Michigan, a private Robert Trent Jones Sr. course opened in 1958: a tree-lined par 72 with big, rolling greens that has…

Rackham Golf Course

In Huntington Woods, next to the Detroit Zoo, the public Donald Ross course the Rackhams gave to Detroit in 1924: a par 71 of…

Rich Harvest Farms

Near Sugar Grove, Illinois, the private course Jerry Rich designed and built on his own farmland: a par 72 of 7,735 yards on published…