Skip to content
Practice

Out of the bunker first time: diagnose this year’s misses and fix them indoors over the winter

The season is ending, but this year's bunker misses still have something to teach. Work out which fault left the ball in the sand, fix it over the winter on a carpet or with a pro, learn how cold and frozen sand change the shot, and know when to putt, chip or take an unplayable under Rule 19.3.

La rédaction Panxis Golf, Canada desk (Élise Tremblay) · · 8 min
A deep greenside bunker cut in front of a green with a yellow flag, with a marsh and pine trees in the background
Photo andrew shelley / Pexels

In brief

  • A ball that stays in means the club dug and slowed; one that flies the green was hit before the sand; one that hits the lip lost its loft.
  • Short backswing, high finish and eyes two inches behind the ball fix most misses, and the entry-point drill works on a carpet all winter.
  • Cold, packed fall sand needs a squarer face and a smaller swing; frozen bunkers are often ground under repair or closed, so check before you play.
  • From a shallow parkland bunker the putter is often safer, and Rule 19.3 lets you drop outside the bunker for two penalty strokes in total.

For most Canadian golfers, the season is either over or down to its last few frosty mornings. That makes now an odd but useful time to think about greenside bunkers. You remember this year’s bad ones clearly: the shot that stayed in, the one that sailed into the rough behind the green, the one that slammed into the lip. Each of those misses left a clue about what went wrong, and you have five months before the snow melts to fix it. This guide explains how to read those clues, which single correction to make, how late-fall and early-spring sand changes the shot, when the explosion shot is a bad bet, and how to keep working on bunker play through a Canadian winter.

Why bunkers cost more than one shot

The expensive part of a bunker is rarely the first swing. It is the second one, played in a hurry by someone annoyed with themselves. A ball that comes out first time, onto the green or even onto the fringe, keeps a bogey a bogey. That is the only target that matters here.

If you want the full setup and swing, our bunker play technique guide covers it. But knowing the method is different from repeating it under pressure. You get no practice swing in the sand, and in a short Canadian season a weekend player might hit only a few dozen greenside bunker shots all year. So the faster route is to identify your one recurring fault rather than rebuild everything.

Three bad results and what caused them

The ball barely moved and stayed in

Cause: the club went in too deep, with the leading edge first, and lost its speed in the sand. Almost always the downswing slowed because part of you feared hitting it too far. This is the most common bunker miss for higher handicaps.

The ball flew the green

Cause: the club met the ball before the sand. Without that layer of sand to cushion impact, a sand wedge sends the ball thirty or forty yards. It usually comes from trying to pick the ball clean, setting it too far back in your stance, or straightening up as you swing down.

The ball hit the lip and fell back

Cause: too little loft at impact. The face closed through the sand, the ball sat too far back, or you used a club with a sharp, straight leading edge and little bounce.

A fourth result, the ball creeping out onto the fringe, is not a fault. It is a success. Distance comes later.

One correction for each fault

For the ball that stays in: protect your speed. Cut the backswing down to roughly shoulder height and commit to a long, high finish. With that proportion, decelerating becomes very difficult. Also open the clubface before you take your grip, so the rounded sole hits the sand first and glides through rather than digging a trench.

For the ball that flies the green: change what you look at. Pick out a spot about two inches behind the ball and keep your eyes on it the whole time. Set the ball slightly forward of centre, roughly in line with your front heel, and keep a little more of your weight on your front side. Weight hanging back makes you scoop, and the scoop sends the leading edge into the ball.

For the ball that hits the lip: keep the face open. Open it before gripping and hold it open through the finish, with the palm of your trail hand pointing up at the end rather than turning over. Play the ball forward. Against a tall lip, a 58 or 60 degree wedge is the right tool; a pitching wedge will not get there.

Late-fall sand, frozen sand and spring sand

If your course is still open in November, the bunkers you meet are not the soft, dry ones of July.

  • Cold, wet and packed. After rain and overnight frost, sand firms up. The club tends to bounce off the surface, and a high-bounce wedge can skip into the ball and blade it. Square the face a little, enter about an inch behind the ball instead of two, and make a shorter swing. The ball will come out lower and run more.
  • Frozen solid. On a cold morning the top of the bunker can freeze. A splash shot off frozen sand is close to impossible and hard on your wrists. Some courses treat bunkers as ground under repair at this time of year, or close them; check the notice at the first tee or ask in the pro shop.
  • Spring. When courses reopen in April or May, bunkers are often wet and heavy from the melt, and some have not been fully restored yet. Expect the same firm, low shot for the first few weeks.
  • Use your feet. You are not allowed to test the sand with your club, but working your feet in for a stance is permitted. If they sink easily, the sand is soft; if they hardly move, it is firm. That tells you which version of the shot to hit.

When you should not splash

Putt. Many Canadian parkland courses have shallow greenside bunkers with a low front edge. If the sand is firm and there is no thick collar of grass to roll through, the putter is a strong option. Hit it about twice as hard as a putt of the same length on the green, ball a little back of centre.

Chip. With a good lie and a low lip, a 9-iron or pitching wedge played like a bump-and-run, ball back, hands ahead and no sand, rolls the ball out safely. It is a clean-contact shot, so it needs a clean lie.

Go out the low side. If the lip toward the flag is beyond your club, find the lowest part of the edge and play there, even if the next shot is longer.

Declare it unplayable. Rule 19.3 allows you to declare a ball unplayable in a bunker. For one penalty stroke, you can replay from your previous spot, or drop in the bunker within two club-lengths or back on the line from the flag through your ball. For two penalty strokes in total, you can drop outside the bunker on that same line. A plugged ball under a steep face is exactly the situation that option was written for.

Bunker Rules in Canada

Golf Canada administers the Rules of Golf in this country; the rules themselves are written jointly by the R&A and the USGA, so they are the same rules played in the United States and overseas. In a bunker:

  • Do not touch the sand with your club right in front of or behind the ball, on a practice swing or on the backswing.
  • You may move loose impediments such as leaves and pine needles, lean on your club, set other clubs down in the bunker and dig in your feet.
  • Local rules matter in the shoulder seasons. A bunker the committee has marked as ground under repair follows that local rule, not the normal bunker rules.

Where to work on your bunker game in Canada this winter

Real sand is scarce between November and April, so plan around that.

  • Indoor golf centres. A few indoor facilities and golf domes include a short-game area, and occasionally a small sand area. Call ahead and ask specifically whether there is sand before you book a bay. Simulators are good for full swings but tell you little about bunker contact.
  • A PGA of Canada professional. The PGA of Canada’s Find a Pro tool searches its members by location and program. Many pros teach indoors through the winter, and a bunker session is worth booking for the spring, when you can work in real sand. Our guide to getting value from golf lessons explains how to prepare.
  • At home. The key skill, striking the ground at the same point every time, can be trained on carpet. Lay a towel on the floor and place a foam ball a few inches in front of it. Make swings that brush the carpet between towel and ball without touching the towel. Ten minutes a few times a week through the winter builds the entry point you need.
  • Early spring. When your club opens, ask whether the practice bunker is ready before the course bunkers are, and spend your first session there instead of on the range.

Your checklist for the first bunker next season

  1. Check whether the bunkers are in play or ground under repair today.
  2. Study the lip and pick your exit point, which may not be the line to the flag.
  3. Choose your shot: splash, putt, chip, low side or unplayable.
  4. Take your highest-lofted wedge, open the face, then grip, choking down slightly.
  5. Dig in your feet and read the sand: soft calls for an open face and more speed; firm or frozen calls for a squarer face and less swing, or another shot altogether.
  6. Look at a spot two inches behind the ball, keep the backswing short, finish high, and rake your marks.

The winter is long enough to turn one recurring bunker fault into a habit you no longer have. Use it, and your first sand shot of the spring will be a lot less stressful than your last one this fall.

One article a day not enough?

The monthly letter gathers what was worth reading, without the noise.

Also worth reading

Parcours de notre annuaire

Blue Devil Golf Club

A public course in Calgary's Bow River valley beside Fish Creek Provincial Park, designed by Gary Browning and Wade Horrocks: 18 holes, par 72…

Bowen Island Golf Club

A nine-hole public course at Cowan Point on Bowen Island, a short ferry ride from Horseshoe Bay: par 35 and 3,003 yards from the…

Brantford Golf & Country Club

A private club on the Grand River in Brantford, Ontario, founded in 1879 and laid out by Nicol Thompson and George Cumming: 18 holes,…