Match play for beginners: gimmes, Stroke Index shots, and why UK matches never touch your Index
Winter knockout draws are going up on club notice boards, and match play is the kindest first competition there is: a disaster costs you one hole. Here is how a match is scored, how shots are given off the Stroke Index, when you can concede a putt, the Rules that behave differently, and why in Great Britain and Ireland a match never touches your handicap.
In brief
- You play one opponent hole by hole. The match ends when one player leads by more holes than are left, written as 3 and 2, and a player level with the holes remaining is dormie.
- In GB&I the singles match play allowance is a mandatory 100 per cent. The lower handicap plays off zero and the other player receives the difference on the holes with Stroke Index 1 upwards.
- Rule 3.2b lets you concede a putt, a hole or the match at any time. A concession cannot be refused or withdrawn, and declaring too high a handicap can disqualify you under Rule 3.2c.
- Loss of hole replaces the two-stroke penalty, order of play matters, and England Golf lists matchplay as not acceptable for handicap purposes, so a winter match cannot hurt your Index.
Some time in the next few weeks a sheet of paper will go up on the board outside the locker room, with a draw on it and a date by which the first round must be played. If you have only ever played medals and Stablefords, a winter knockout can look like something for the low handicappers. It is not. Match play is the gentlest way into competitive golf, because you only have one opponent, and the seven you ran up on the 5th costs you that hole and nothing more. Below you will find how a match is scored, how the strokes on the card’s Stroke Index row decide who gets a shot where, when you can give a putt, the handful of Rules that change, and one British detail worth knowing before you sign up: whatever happens in your match, it will not touch your Handicap Index.
Holes, not shots
Forget the running total. In a match you and your opponent each play the hole, the lower score wins it, and if you take the same number the hole is halved. Penalty strokes count as usual, and in a handicap match your shots are taken off before the two scores are compared. What you keep track of is the number of holes one player is ahead. Win the 1st and you are one up. Lose the 2nd and you are back to all square. After eleven holes you might be three down, which sounds grim and is nothing of the kind with seven to play.
A match finishes as soon as one player cannot be caught. Three up with two holes left means the match is over, and the result is written as “3 and 2”. If the lead is exactly the number of holes remaining, say two up with two to play, the leader is “dormie”, and the opponent has to win both just to draw level. A match that reaches the 18th green and goes no further than one hole either way is won “one up” or “two up”.
What happens if it is all square after 18 depends on the event. Club knockouts normally carry on down the 1st, then the 2nd, until somebody wins a hole, while a friendly fourball in the bar afterwards will happily call it a half. Settle the question before you tee off, not on the 18th green with the light fading.
Two habits save arguments. Say the state of the match out loud walking to every tee, “you’re one up through 9”, so you both agree on it. And if you mark a card, put a plus, a minus or a nought next to each hole rather than strokes, so the story of the afternoon can be checked at a glance.
Shots in a handicap match and the Stroke Index row
Imagine a 13 handicapper drawn against a member who plays off 24. Each of you works out a Course Handicap for the tees you are playing from, which the chart near the 1st tee or your union’s app will give you. In Great Britain and Ireland the handicap allowance for singles match play is 100 per cent, and the guidance issued for GB&I states that the allowances in the WHS tables are mandatory, not a suggestion. The better player then plays off nothing and the other receives the difference, so our 24 gets eleven shots.
Where those shots fall is not a matter of choice. Look at the scorecard and find the column headed S.I., for Stroke Index, which ranks the holes from 1, the hardest, to 18. With eleven shots you get one on each hole with a Stroke Index of 1 to 11. On those holes a five becomes a net four, and if your opponent also takes four the hole is halved. On the other seven holes it is level.
Agree the numbers on the 1st tee, with your phones out if need be. Rule 3.2c places the responsibility on the players, and the consequences are lopsided. If you declare a handicap that is too low, you simply play off the lower figure. If you declare one that is too high and it changes the shots given or received, and you do not put it right before your opponent plays their next stroke, you are disqualified from the match. Nobody wants to lose a knockout tie that way.
The gimme, properly
Match play is where the “gimme” lives, and it is in the Rules rather than a matter of manners. Rule 3.2b allows you to concede your opponent’s next stroke, a hole or the whole match at any point before the result is settled. A conceded putt counts as holed and the ball can be picked up by either player. The concession has to be clear, which can mean saying “that’s good” or knocking the ball back to its owner, and once made it cannot be withdrawn, nor can your opponent decline it and insist on putting.
There are no gimmes in a medal, and picking up a short one without holing out there leads to disqualification if you do not correct it. In a match, giving a two-footer is simply part of the game. Be generous early on. It sets a pleasant tone, and if you later make your opponent hole a four-footer on the 17th, that is perfectly within your rights and every bit as traditional.
The same Rule lets you concede a hole you cannot win. If your opponent is on the green in two and you are hacking out of gorse in three, shake hands on that hole and walk to the next tee. Do not assume a putt has been given because the last one was, and never rake your own ball away and call it good. If nobody said anything, you putt.
Five Rules that behave differently
Most of the Rules are identical in medal and match play. These are the ones that catch out newcomers.
Loss of hole replaces two strokes. Where a medal would add the general penalty of two shots, a match hands the hole to your opponent. Play the wrong ball, or brush the sand in a bunker with a practice swing, and the hole is gone. Too many clubs in the bag is treated differently: the state of the match is adjusted by one hole for each hole on which the breach happened, with a ceiling of two holes.
Order of play counts. The player further from the hole plays first. Playing out of turn carries no penalty, but under Rule 6.4a your opponent may cancel the stroke and ask you to play again. That usually happens to the best chip you hit all day.
You must tell the truth about your score. Rule 3.2d says that when your opponent asks how many you have taken, during or after a hole, you give the right number, and that you let them know about any penalty as soon as reasonably possible. A wrong number left uncorrected can cost you the hole.
Doubts are raised on the spot. If you think your opponent has broken a Rule, say so then and there. In a club competition you can ask for a ruling, and the request normally has to be made before either of you plays from the next tee.
You may practise on the course beforehand. Rule 5.2a allows a player to practise on the course before a match play round on the day, which is not the case in stroke play. A Local Rule can switch this off, so read the notice board before you wander out with three balls to the 9th green.
Why a British winter suits a match
From November to March the course seems built to ruin a medal card. Fairway mats on some tees, a temporary green or two, preferred lies through the green, frost delays that squeeze the day into a few hours, leaves that hide a perfectly good drive, and a par 4 of 420 yards that plays like 470 in the wet. Lose a ball in that and a stroke play total takes a three-shot hit. In a match it is one hole, and the next tee starts the slate afresh.
The format also moves along. With putts conceded and lost holes picked up, a tie that ends 6 and 5 on the 13th green gets both of you back to the clubhouse while it is still light, and a newer player who worries about holding up the group behind has one less thing on their mind.
And it rewards the sort of golf a higher handicapper can actually play. You do not have to avoid every disaster, only win more holes than you lose. When your opponent has found the ditch, aim for the fat part of the green. When you are two down with three left, go at the flag, because a bogey will not save you anyway.
Where to play a match this winter in the UK
The board at your own club. Many clubs run a winter knockout, a winter league or a singles and pairs match play through the colder months, with a deadline for each round and the two players left to fix a date between themselves. It is the easiest first competition there is, because only one person is watching you play, and the handicap secretary or the competition committee will tell you how to enter.
Your handicap is not involved. This is where Britain differs from some other countries. England Golf’s frequently asked questions for clubs list the formats acceptable for handicap purposes as individual Medal, Stableford, Par/Bogey and Max Score, plus fourball better-ball competition scores, and say that other team formats and matchplay are currently not acceptable. A score from a match therefore never goes on your record, and there is no “most likely score” to work out for conceded holes, a procedure the GB&I guidance describes as not in general use here. Winter is a different story for medals. The same guidance states that active and inactive seasons are not implemented in GB&I, so a winter Stableford can still count if the course meets the conditions on the day. If you want to protect your Index from frost and temporary greens, a match is the one competition that cannot hurt it.
Watching it done well. The R&A’s Amateur Championship is decided by match play. A field of 288 plays 36 holes of stroke play over two courses, the leading 64 and ties go through, and from there it is 18-hole matches until a final over 36 holes. The later rounds are worth following next summer for the concessions, the dormie finishes and the moments when a player who is up decides to take the safe line.
If competitions are new to you, our guide to your first competition covers entering and signing a card, and our piece on the formats of play at UK clubs explains medals, Stablefords and the pairs formats you will also meet on the board.
Before you shake hands on the 1st tee
- Work out both Course Handicaps for your tees, play the lower one off zero and give the difference at 100 per cent.
- Find the Stroke Index row on the card and mark the holes where shots are received.
- Agree what happens if you are all square after 18, and check the club’s deadline for the round.
- Call the state of the match on every tee and keep a plus, minus or nought for each hole.
- Give short putts clearly, never take one for granted, and concede a hole once it is lost.
- Remember loss of hole instead of two shots, the order of play, and an honest answer when asked your score.
- Read the notice board for a Local Rule on practising on the course before your match.
Your first knockout tie is a relaxed afternoon against one person, played a hole at a time, with your handicap left safely in the locker. Put your name on the sheet.






