Skip to content
Tournaments

Match play for beginners: concessions, strokes and playing matches in Canada’s off-season

In a match, a seven on a cold par 3 costs you one hole and nothing more. With the posting season closed in most provinces, here is how match play is scored, how concessions and handicap strokes work, which Rules change from stroke play, and where the format fits in the Canadian calendar.

La rédaction Panxis Golf, Canada desk (Élise Tremblay) · · 10 min
An empty green in autumn, a yellow flag in the foreground, in front of a row of tall trees, some of them turning orange and purple
Photo Abdel Achkouk / Pexels

In brief

  • You play one opponent hole by hole. The match is over when one player leads by more holes than remain, as in 4 and 3, and dormie means leading by exactly the holes left.
  • Rule 3.2b lets you concede a stroke, a hole or the match at any time. A concession must be clear and cannot be refused or withdrawn.
  • Golf Canada applies the Rules of Handicapping, which recommend 100% of the Course Handicap difference in singles match play, received on the holes ranked 1 upward on the card.
  • Posting closed on October 31 in Ontario and Quebec and on November 15 in British Columbia, so off-season matches do not affect your Index. In season, match play scores count.

Picture a par 3 of 160 yards in late October with a cold wind off the lake. Your tee shot finds the water, the drop goes long, and you walk off with a seven. In a stroke play event that seven sits on your card for the rest of the day and drags your total with it. In a match against a friend, it costs you exactly one hole, and on the next tee the slate is clean. That is the whole appeal of match play for a golfer who is still learning: you compete against one person, one hole at a time, and a disaster never counts more than once. With the posting season closed across most of Canada and the courses that stay open now playing firm and frosty, it is also the best way to keep a weekly game meaningful. Below you will find how the score of a match works, when a putt or a hole can be given, how handicap strokes are shared, which Rules behave differently from stroke play, and where match play fits in the Canadian golf calendar.

Holes, not strokes: keeping the score of a match

Each hole is a contest of its own. Whoever takes fewer strokes on it wins the hole, penalty strokes included, and in a net match the handicap strokes count too. Equal scores mean the hole is halved and the match stays where it was. So instead of a running total of 41 or 47, the score of a match is a gap between two players: “2 up” if you have won two more holes than your opponent, “1 down” if you trail by one, “all square” when you are level.

A match does not always go the full eighteen. It is over the moment one player leads by more holes than remain. Lead by four with three to play and you have won “4 and 3”; the last three holes can be played for fun, but they no longer count. One position deserves a name of its own. When you lead by exactly as many holes as are left, say 3 up with three to play, you are “dormie,” and your opponent has to win every remaining hole just to draw level.

What happens if nobody is ahead after the 18th depends on the competition. A club knockout normally sends the players back out to the 1st hole, and the first player to win a hole takes the match. In a Saturday game between friends, a halved match is a perfectly respectable result, and many players prefer it that way.

Make a habit of stating the score on every tee. “I’m 1 down through 9” takes a couple of seconds and prevents a long discussion on the 17th green about whether the 5th was halved. A small mark next to each hole on the card, a plus, a minus or a zero, lets either of you rebuild the whole story of the match in a few seconds.

Handing out strokes when handicaps differ

Take a player with a Course Handicap of 8 who plays someone with a Course Handicap of 19. Off level terms, the higher handicap has little chance, and the match is no fun for either of them. The Rules of Handicapping, which Golf Canada applies across the country, recommend an allowance of 100% for individual match play. Each player calculates a Course Handicap for the tees being used, the better player plays off zero, and the other receives the full difference. Here that means eleven strokes.

Those eleven strokes are not spent wherever the receiver likes. Look along the scorecard for the row labelled “Handicap” or “HCP”: it ranks the holes from 1, the hardest, to 18, the easiest. With eleven strokes you get one on each hole ranked 1 to 11. On those holes one stroke comes off your score before it is compared with your opponent’s, so a six on the hole ranked 3 becomes a net five, which halves the hole against your opponent’s five and wins it against their six.

Agree on the numbers on the first tee, before a ball is struck, because Rule 3.2c makes this the players’ responsibility. If you declare a handicap that is too high, the number of strokes changes as a result, and you have not corrected it before your opponent makes their next stroke, you are disqualified. Declare one that is too low and nothing happens to you, other than playing off the lower figure. The easiest way to avoid any doubt is to check both handicaps together in your Golf Canada accounts before you start.

Giving a putt, giving a hole: concessions

The “gimme” that so many casual golfers use without thinking only has a place in the Rules in match play. Rule 3.2b allows you to concede your opponent’s next stroke, a hole, or the entire match at any time before the result is decided. A conceded putt counts as holed, and either player may pick the ball up. The concession has to be clear, either spoken or shown by an obvious action such as knocking the ball back, and once given it can be neither declined by your opponent nor withdrawn by you.

Compare that with stroke play, where nothing is ever given and a player who lifts the ball without holing out is disqualified unless the mistake is corrected in time. A few good habits make concessions work for you:

  • Be generous from the start. Conceding an 18-inch putt on the 2nd hole sets a relaxed, friendly tone for the round. Asking your opponent to hole a four-footer on the 16th when the match is tight is just as legitimate; it is part of the tactics of the format.
  • Give up a hole that is already lost. When your opponent is on the green in two and you are playing your fourth from a pile of leaves under the trees, concede the hole and move on. Nobody minds, and the round speeds up.
  • Never assume. A putt that was given on the 6th says nothing about the one on the 7th. If you did not hear a concession, you putt.

What changes from stroke play

The large majority of Rules work the same way in both formats. A handful do not, and they are the ones a first-time match player tends to meet the hard way.

Penalties cost holes, not strokes. Wherever stroke play applies the general penalty of two strokes, match play applies loss of hole. Hit your opponent’s ball by mistake, or ground your club in the sand of a bunker during a practice swing, and the hole goes to the other player. Carrying more than fourteen clubs is handled differently: the state of the match is adjusted by deducting one hole for each hole where the breach happened, to a maximum of two holes.

Tell the truth about your score, and say so quickly. Rule 3.2d requires you to give your opponent the correct number of strokes taken when they ask, during the hole or after it, and to let them know as soon as reasonably possible when you have incurred a penalty. A wrong number that is not corrected in time can cost you the hole.

The order of play is enforceable. The ball farther from the hole is played first. Playing out of turn carries no penalty, but under Rule 6.4a your opponent may cancel the stroke and ask you to play it again in the proper order. Hole a chip out of turn and see it recalled once, and you will never forget the Rule.

Practice on the course is allowed beforehand. Before a stroke play round, practising on the course is generally not permitted. Rule 5.2a takes the opposite approach for match play: you may practise on the course before a match on the same day. A club can restrict that with a Local Rule, so read the competition notice before you head out to roll putts on the 18th green.

Doubts are settled between the two of you. If you believe your opponent has breached a Rule, raise it on the spot rather than three holes later. In a club competition an unresolved point can go to the Committee as a request for a ruling, and timing matters: in general it should be made before either player tees off on the next hole.

Why the format fits the short days

Late-season and off-season golf is hard on a stroke play total. Fairways are firm, greens can be slow or replaced by temporary ones, a frost delay eats the morning, and preferred lies are often in force under a Local Rule. A ball that disappears in a pile of wet leaves can add three strokes in stroke play. In a match, it costs one hole.

Matches also move faster. Short putts are given, lost holes are conceded, and a match that ends 6 and 5 lets both players head for the clubhouse before the light goes, which in a Toronto November happens before five in the afternoon. For a newer golfer who worries about holding up the group behind, that speed is worth as much as the format itself.

There is a quieter benefit too. Match play rewards decisions more than perfection. If your opponent has just hit into the trees, the smart play is to the fat part of the green; if you are 2 down with three holes left, you can take on a flag you would normally avoid. Learning when to attack and when to protect is a skill that carries over to every round you play next season.

Where match play fits in Canada this off-season

Your handicap is on pause, so play for the result. Golf Canada lists the active posting season by province, and in Ontario and Quebec it runs from April 15 to October 31, while British Columbia’s ends on November 15. By now none of those windows is open, so a match you play in the coming weeks will not touch your Handicap Index. That is a good reason to play matches purely for the pleasure of winning or losing them. Keep the posting rule in mind for spring, though: match play rounds are acceptable for handicap in the active season, and on a hole you did not finish because it was conceded, Golf Canada asks you to record your most likely score for that hole, and the usual net double bogey limit still applies.

Golfers on the coast. On the British Columbia coast, golf carries on through much of the year when the weather allows. A regular match with the same partner, carried over from week to week, is the simplest way to give those damp rounds a purpose until club competitions return.

Ask your club about spring. Club match play events, knockouts and ladders in particular, usually give each pairing a few weeks to play its round at a time both players agree on. Ask your pro shop or your men’s or ladies’ section whether one is planned for next season. It is a gentle first step into competition, because only one other player is watching your swing.

Watch the best amateurs do it. Golf Ontario has contested the Ontario Men’s Match Play Championship every year since 1986, with a senior division alongside it. The 2024 edition at Tarandowah Golfers Club brought together 96 men and senior men after almost 400 players had tried to qualify across the province, and Josh DiCarlo won the final 4 and 3. Following the results next June is a good way to see dormie positions and tactical concessions in action.

If you are new to club events, our guides to your first competition and to the main formats of play cover what you will meet in your first season, and our list of Rules golfers often get wrong is worth a read before you tee it up.

Checklist for your first match

  • Work out both Course Handicaps for the tees you are playing. The lower one plays off zero, the other receives the full difference on the holes ranked 1 upward on the card.
  • Decide before the first tee shot what happens if the match is all square after 18.
  • Say the score of the match on every tee and mark a plus, a minus or a zero for each hole.
  • Concede short putts clearly, never take a concession for granted, and give up a hole once it is gone.
  • Remember the main changes: loss of hole instead of two strokes, order of play, and an honest count of your strokes whenever your opponent asks.

Your first match is a low-pressure way into competitive golf. One opponent, one hole at a time, and the worst hole of your day only ever costs you one.

One article a day not enough?

The monthly letter gathers what was worth reading, without the noise.

Also worth reading

Parcours de notre annuaire

Canadian Golf and Country Club

Twenty-seven holes on farm ground at Ashton since 1975, played as a par 72 West and a par 70 East: the East is the…

Dundarave Golf Course

A Hurdzan and Fry course opened in 1999 to show off Prince Edward Island's red sandstone: 7,089 yards and 120 bunkers filled with red…

St Charles Country Club

The only club on earth where Donald Ross and Alister MacKenzie each built nine holes: Bendelow in 1905, Ross in 1919, MacKenzie's North nine…