Skip to content
Practice

One chipping club or three? Muddy winter lies, preferred lies on the apron and the links putter

Winter mud leaves a lofted wedge almost no margin, and slow greens stop a chip that lands too softly. One club for everything or a putting-style stroke with three: each has a price. A favourite club, two stand-ins and twenty minutes on the chipping green settle it.

La rédaction Panxis Golf, UK desk (Rachel Owen) · · 10 min
A golf ball rolls across a green toward a yellow flag; in the foreground, seen from behind, the legs of a player in lime-green trousers, and a second player waiting by the flag
Photo Kampus Production / Pexels

In brief

  • Read the lie before the flag: mud under the ball, depth of grass, what must be carried and how a slow winter green will take the first bounce.
  • One wedge gathers all your practice but needs several swings; three clubs need one putting-style stroke, the method Paul Runyan, PGA champion in 1934 and 1938, taught.
  • Under Model Local Rule E-3 you place once within the distance your Committee sets, normally on closely mown grass, which usually includes the apron.
  • On firm fescue and bent links turf the putter and the running 7-iron come first; Rule 4.1b caps the bag at 14 clubs, so a chipper costs a place.

Second Saturday in November, the roll-up is on the 4th, and your ball has stopped on the apron with a smear of mud on one side and wet, thin turf underneath. One of your partners plays every greenside shot with a 56-degree wedge and would not dream of changing. Another reaches for a 7-iron and trundles it up like a long putt. You stand between them with three clubs in your hand, which is exactly the problem. British winter golf makes the old argument sharper than any summer evening does, because soft ground punishes a poor strike and slow greens swallow a ball that lands too softly. So which is it: one chipping club, or several? Here is how to answer that for your own game, on your own course, before the spring medals.

Start with the ground, not the flag

In July you can get away with choosing a chip by distance alone. In November the lie has the first vote, and it often has the casting one too. Look down before you look up, and ask four things.

Is there mud or water under the ball? A soggy lie leaves almost no room for error with a lofted club. Catch the ground a centimetre early and the head stops dead. Coaches do not even agree on whether more or less bounce helps from mud, which tells you how narrow the margin is. A straighter-faced club swung like a putter barely brushes the turf, so there is less to go wrong.

Is the ball down in the grass? Semi-rough that has stopped growing but is still wet clings to the clubhead. A ball nestled in it needs loft and a slightly steeper hit. Leave the 7-iron in the bag.

What must the ball clear? A yard of apron is no obstacle. A greenside swale full of casual water, a bunker lip or two paces of rough set the least loft you can use.

How will the green receive it? Winter putting surfaces are usually slower and softer than in summer. A ball that pitched and ran eight paces in August may pull up after four. Slopes matter as well: landing into an upslope kills the run, landing on a downslope adds to it.

Only once those four are answered does the choice of club mean anything.

Every chip is a short flight and a long run

A chip is the low greenside shot that travels further along the ground than through the air. A pitch is the reverse. To plan a chip you need two things in your head: the place where the ball will first touch down, and the distance it will run from there.

Loft shares out the journey. A straighter face sends the ball out lower with less spin, so it runs. A more lofted face throws it higher and it settles sooner. That leaves two routes to the same hole. Either the stroke stays constant and the club changes, or the club stays constant and the stroke changes. The whole one-club-or-three debate is nothing more than that.

Whichever you favour, aim to pitch the ball on the putting surface, a pace or so on, where the first bounce is true. An apron in winter is a lottery: one ball skids, the next plugs in a soft patch.

The single wedge: all the practice in one place

Golfers who chip with one wedge are not being stubborn. Feel is built by repeating the same thing, and a single club collects every repetition. Its owner knows how the sole reacts to a bare lie, what a hip-high swing produces, and how the ball leaves the face from light rough. With no club to choose, the mind is free for the lie and the landing point.

The bill arrives in the number of swings required. Making a 56-degree wedge scuttle 12 yards across a green means pushing the hands ahead, playing the ball back and delofting the face. Making it sit down means the opposite. Those are separate skills. Tour players build them over thousands of hours, which is why so many of them stick with one wedge. A club golfer who plays at weekends has to keep three variations sharp on very little practice, and in winter mud each variation is another chance to hit it heavy or thin.

Long chips make it worse. If the hole is 20 yards away and you insist on the sand wedge, most of that distance has to be flown, which needs a bigger swing, and a bigger swing magnifies a mistake.

Several clubs: one stroke, borrowed from the putter

The other school holds the stroke still and lets the club do the adjusting. Its best-known champion was Paul Runyan, PGA Championship winner in 1934 and 1938 and for decades afterwards a celebrated short-game teacher. Runyan chipped with an action modelled on his putting stroke and picked the club according to how much run he needed.

Most players who follow him carry three options: a sand or gap wedge, a 9-iron and a 7-iron. You will hear a rule of thumb for what each does, usually called the rule of 12: take the number on the iron away from 12 and you have the ratio of roll to carry. By that reckoning a 7-iron runs five times as far as it flies, an 8-iron four times, a 9-iron three, a pitching wedge twice, and a sand wedge runs about as far as it carries.

It is folklore, not physics. Different versions quote different ratios, the lofts stamped on modern irons are stronger than those the saying grew up with, and a damp December green will make a nonsense of any chart drawn up for a dry one. The useful part is the sequence: with the same stroke, each less-lofted club runs further.

What this method gives you is a simple, repeatable movement and a ball that is on the ground early, behaving like a putt. Even a slightly thinned 7-iron ends up in the right postcode. What it asks is that you keep three sets of distances in your hands, grip down on the longer shaft, and accept that the ball jumps off a 7-iron face more quickly than you expect. It is also useless when the ball cannot escape low: from a buried lie, or with a bunker in the way.

A favourite and two stand-ins

Most handicap golfers end up between the camps, and it is a sensible place to be. Choose one favourite club and allow yourself two stand-ins.

  • The favourite: a 9-iron or pitching wedge for any ordinary lie. It clears a couple of feet of apron and then runs, and it is the club you practise with nine times out of ten.
  • Stand-in one, plenty of green to use: hole at the back, nothing to carry. Drop to a 7-iron, or a hybrid held with your putting grip. Identical stroke, longer run.
  • Stand-in two, no green to use: a bunker, bank or patch of rough to carry and the hole cut close. Take the sand wedge. Here the one-club players have it right.

There is a fourth choice that is not a chip at all. When the grass between ball and green is short and reasonably dry, the putter removes the duff and the thin from the list of outcomes. Our piece on winter chipping on links, heathland and parkland goes through when to trust it. And if you are unsure what the soles of your own wedges were designed for, choosing your wedges explains bounce and grind.

Where a British winter changes the answer: mud, preferred lies, links and parkland

Preferred lies reach the apron. Many clubs run Model Local Rule E-3 through the winter. It lets you lift, clean and place the ball within a distance set by the Committee, often six inches, not nearer the hole. The rule is normally limited to closely mown areas, meaning grass cut to fairway height or less, and that description usually takes in the apron round the green. So a muddy ball on the fringe may be one you are entitled to wipe and set on the best blade of grass within reach. Read the notice in the pro shop or on the first tee for the exact distance and the areas covered, and remember you place once: after that the ball is in play. In England, rounds played under the rule remain acceptable for handicap. A placed ball on a decent lie changes the sum completely, because the low runner with a 9-iron is suddenly the safe shot again.

Wet parkland. Inland courses on heavy soil are where the lofted wedge suffers most from November to March. The turf under the ball is soft, the greens are slow and receptive, and a chip pitched to its summer spot finishes well short. Land it further on than you think, or go down a club and let it roll. If the ball is in the rough beside the green, where E-3 normally does not apply, loft is unavoidable: take the sand wedge and commit to it.

Links and fine-grass courses. Seaside turf is a different game. Links are built on sand and their fairways and surrounds are traditionally fine fescue and browntop bent, grasses that stay firm and tight under the ball even in winter. There is no cushion for a wedge to slide through, and the ground game is the percentage play: putter from 10 or 15 yards off, hybrid, or a 7-iron running along the contours. Members at links clubs grow up doing this, and it is why visitors armed only with a lob wedge find the greensides so awkward.

Practising it. Most clubs have a short-game area, though in winter it may be roped off or restricted to mats, so check before you tip out a bag of balls. A PGA professional can watch your three clubs for half an hour and tell you which stroke is costing you. The PGA trains and accredits club professionals, while England Golf, Scottish Golf and Wales Golf look after handicapping in their own countries. And a range mat, for all its faults, is a fair place to groove the putting-style stroke with a 7-iron when the chipping green is shut.

Twenty minutes that decide it

Take eight balls, a sand wedge, a 9-iron and a 7-iron to the chipping green on a dry-ish afternoon. Pick a level chip of about 12 paces with a yard or two of apron to cross, and lay a headcover one pace on to the green as your landing mark.

First, learn your own ratios. Eight balls with each club, the same compact stroke every time, aiming only at the headcover. Walk to where each cluster has stopped and pace it out. Those three figures are yours, on that grass, in that season, and they beat the rule of 12.

Second, score the two methods. Now play to the hole. Eight balls using the sand wedge alone, then eight where you pick whichever club suits. For each set, count the balls that finish within a putter’s length, and make a separate note of the two worst. The worst ones are the double bogeys.

Third, change the question. Move to a short-sided chip with little green to work with and run the second step again.

If the wedge alone comes out ahead both times, stay with it and spend your practice on varying the flight. If picking the club wins, and above all if your two worst are less ugly with the straighter faces, adopt the favourite and two stand-ins. Note the ratios on the back of a scorecard and repeat the exercise in April, when the greens quicken and every number stretches.

What the Rules say about your options

Rule 4.1b allows 14 clubs and no more. Running the ball up with a 7-iron or a hybrid uses clubs you already carry, whether the chip is 8 yards or 25 yards. A purpose-made chipper is legal, but it takes one of the 14 places, so something else has to stay in the boot.

Your card for Saturday

  • Look at the lie before the flag: mud, depth of grass, what has to be carried, how the green will take it.
  • If preferred lies are in force and your ball is on closely mown grass, clean it and place it once, within the distance on the notice.
  • Choose where the ball will land, a pace on to the green, and say it to yourself.
  • Use the favourite club unless there is plenty of green (go straighter) or none (go more lofted).
  • On tight, firm turf, links above all, reach for the putter first.
  • Afterwards, jot down each chip that finished outside a putter’s length and the club you used.

Neither camp is right for everyone. The answer depends on how much you practise and which miss hurts you most, and a damp half hour on the chipping green this month will tell you more than a winter of debate in the bar.

One article a day not enough?

The monthly letter gathers what was worth reading, without the noise.

Also worth reading

Parcours de notre annuaire

Blairmore and Strone Golf Club

A nine-hole hill course above Strone, near Dunoon on the Cowal Peninsula, opened in 1896 and credited to James Braid: par 31 and 1,896…

Burnham Beeches Golf Club

Buckinghamshire's oldest golf club, founded in 1891 at Burnham beside the Burnham Beeches woodland: an 18-hole, tree-lined parkland course, par 70 and 6,365 yards…

Denbigh Golf Club

Denbigh Golf Club, formed in 1908 and revived in 1922 on its present ground off Henllan Road: an 18-hole parkland course among mature trees,…